There are days when you just want creamy, carby, comfort food but alas! Need to watch the calories because you're responsible and keeping track to make sure you don't go over your daily intake. Hear me out - it's possible to have it all. This super yum creamy mushroom pasta recipe has all the creaminess that you love WITHOUT any cream added.
Sounds good? I bet.
Jump to:
Swap cream with milk!
How do you make a creamy mushroom sauce without cream you ask. The secret: bechamel sauce. You know that lovely, thick, creamy top layer of a lasagne? Use that!
Basic bechamel sauce (aka white sauce)
Really simple, bechamel sauce is made of butter, milk, flour, salt and pepper. You can jazz it up by adding some nutmeg if you're in the mood.
By simply swapping out the cream with a healthier option - bechamel sauce, you've got a healthier, lower in calories yet delicious creamy mushroom pasta!
Ingredients
- Lemon juice for this recipe is super important. It'll add a lemony tang to the pasta, works perfectly with the creaminess of this mushroom sauce. Honestly, without a squeeze or two of lemon juice, this pasta will be pretty flat.
- Parsley adds freshness to the pasta and a lovely aroma too. Definitely use fresh parsley here - not the dried stuff.
- Veggie stock can substitute for chicken stock if you're following a vegetarian diet. This will just help the mushrooms out and add more flavour into the dish.
- Milk you're already being mindful by swapping cream out with milk, use full cream milk/whole milk.
- Mushrooms I prefer using brown/swish mushrooms as I find they have more flavour than white button mushrooms. However when I went shopping for this recipe, white mushrooms were on sale.. I had to!
Step by step instructions
There are roughly two parts to this.
Get as much flavour onto the mushrooms as possible
Here is an important tip.
You want to really add a good colour on the mushrooms first. Colour means flavour. Which means flavourful mushrooms. Get it nice and golden brown by cooking on high heat. Stirring every minute or 2, this part will take about 5 or 6 minutes.
Once the mushrooms look like above image #4, remove from pan and set aside.
Making the bechamel sauce (white sauce)
Once the butter has melted and flour mixed in, make sure to slowly incorporate the milk in. Stirring constantly, add a little milk in at a time. Best use a whisk for this step or at least get the whisk out for any stubborn lumpy bits that just won't go away.
Once the sauce is smooth, let it simmer for a minute before mixing in the sauteed mushrooms, stock and seasoning (salt and pepper).
Creamy alfredo sauce?
If you want, mix in some grated parmesan or cheddar cheese at this stage. This will then be an alfredo sauce. But be mindful.. if you add a lot then it defeats the purpose of making the healthy version of a creamy mushroom pasta. Heck, just an option if you decide to opt-out half-way through cooking.
No! you're committed to a healthy pasta today. Stick to it. Only a little freshly grated parmesan to serve.
Look at how creamy it is and it's all possible with some milk, flour and butter!
Don't worry, you don't need much butter at all to make a delicious bechamel sauce (white sauce).
I used spaghetti to go with this healthy creamy mushroom sauce but feel free to have a bit of fun and use other shapes such as penne, fettuccine or if you dare.. macaroni pasta.
Variations
- Add some rotisserie chicken breasts for a more balanced meal - more protein and fewer carbs.
- Mix in some spinach leaves to add some greens in your meal if you can't be bothered to make a side of salad.
- Try this recipe with a mix of different mushroom varieties! Such as oyster, porcini, shimeji, enoki, etc. The flavours will be even better!
Other delicious healthy pasta recipes you might like
- Vegetarian bolognese ft. roast pumpkin - vegan and packed full of flavour!
- Healthy-ish chicken and broccoli pasta - delicious yet light
- Easy garlic prawn pasta - 15 minute, tangy flavour bomb
Thank you for checking out my recipes! Let me know what you think and/or if you have any questions, drop me a note in the comments section below. 🙂
Happy cooking!
📖 Recipe
Creamy mushroom pasta (healthy!)
Ingredients
- 400 g /14 oz swiss/brown mushrooms button mushrooms, thickly sliced
- 400 g /14 oz dried spaghetti or your choice of pasta shape
- 1 brown onion finely diced
- 2 cloves garlic minced
- 2 tablespoon olive oil
- 2 tablespoon lemon juice or juice of 1 lemon (note 1)
- ½ cup fresh parsley finely sliced (note 2)
- salt and pepper to taste
Bechamel sauce w/ veggie stock
- 2 cups milk
- 1 cup vegetable stock or chicken stock
- 2 tablespoon plain flour
- 50 g /2oz butter or 4 tablespoon butter
To serve (optional)
- Freshly grated parmesan cheese
Instructions
- Cook pasta according to packet instructions. Reserve ½ cup of pasta cooking water. Make sure to salt the pasta cooking water, about 1 - 2 tbsp.
- In a large skillet/pan, cook onions until lightly golden and soft. On medium heat for about 5 minutes.
- Add minced garlic and stir through for 30 seconds or until garlic is fragrant.
- Add sliced mushrooms and turn the heat to high. Cook mushrooms until golden brown. This will take about 5 - 6 minutes. Remove and set aside. (note 3)
- Same pan, melt butter on low heat then stir in flour.
- Once flour and butter have comebined, slowly pour in milk. Stiring constantly. Best use a whisk at this stage. The sauce should be quite thick.
- Now, slowly pour in vegetable stock as you whisk the sauce. The stock will loosen the sauce up into a smooth creamy sauce. Allow sauce to simmer for 1 minute.
- Add sauteed mushrooms, lemon juice, salt and pepper. Mix thoroughly. Continue to cook on low heat. Taste the sauce and adjust for seasoning.
- Mix in cooked pasta and fresh parsley. Thoroughly mix the sauce into the pasta, for about 2 minutes. If the sauce needs loosening, mix in some of the reserved pasta cooking water.
- Optional (but highly recommended): serve with freshly grated parmesan cheese.
Paula J
haven't tried the recipe yet, but am shocked to see "Make sure to salt the pasta cooking water, about 1 - 2 tbsp". 1 - 2 TABLEspoons of salt, I would put less than a teaspoon in a large saucepan of water. Are you sure you mean tablespoons???
Will try recipe soon but with far less salt!
Genevieve
Hi Paula, yes! I meant tablespoons! It may sound like a lot but vast majority of the salt will be discarded (along with the cooking water) and only some will actually go into the pasta. 🙂
Kat
I’ve been looking for the perfect mushroom béchamel recipe but somehow it never hit the mark. This is the first time I’m trying your recipe and it’s exactly what I was looking for. The perfect blend of creaminess and mushroom flavor. I added some red chili flakes for an extra kick. So good! this one is a keeper for sure.
Genevieve
Hi Kat, thank you so much for your lovely review. Really happy that this recipe hit the mark for you! 🙂
Tash
I haven't made this delightful dish yet.....just found it now. But when making my bechamel I use extra virgin olive oil instead of butter & skim milk, to make it even more healthy! I don't see a difference in taste, although I have to admit I find full cream milk, butter very rich & they give me tummy issues. I was wondering, as you add lemon juice to add zing, could you use Greek yogurt instead of Bechamel sauce & the lemon juice? It's super healthy, creamy & has it's sour notes to replace the lemon? What do you think? Like I said I just found you, & will be a regular visitor from now😁! Thankyou for taking the time making these scrummy dishes & sharing them with us!
Genevieve
Hi Tash, thank you so much for your lovely note! I've never tried using Greek yoghurt instead however, I suspect it might curddle in the cooking process. So if you'd like to give it a go, I suggest turning the heat off then mix in Greek yoghurt and a little pasta cooking water to loosen. For extra flavour, you could add some chicken/veg stock powder. Hopefully this will prevent the curddling from happening. Keep in mind, curddling won't impact the flavour so even if it does, it should still taste good. Oh and the zing from lemon juice is on the subtle side whereas Greek yoghurt's tanginess would be stronger. Hope it turns out the way you like it! -Gen
Angela
Can you use a milk substitute like oat milk?
Genevieve
Hi Angela, I've not tried using oat milk for this recipe before however I suspect it might curdle!
Aditi Aditi
Best recipe ever, I am a vegetarian and this recipe is best suited to me as I don't use egg. Thanks so much for posting it.
Genevieve
Glad you like this! Thanks for your kind comment Aditi 🙂
Jojo
Absolutely delicious... My 1st experience with mushrooms was very successful. I'm officially a new fan.
Genevieve
That's fantastic to hear Jojo! 😀 Mushrooms are awesome!